It is somewhat scary that nearly a year has passed since I started this blog. At the time I expected the basic diorama to be finished by Xmas.
Gosh, you have to laugh.
So many things have changed. on so many levels. For instance I really thought the use of Tillig track might be a long term way forward. I really didn't expect to be sat here with a bunch of EM track components. If I'm honest I'd probably massively over estimated how far the RTR market had developed. The truth is it remains a starting point and nothing more.
Look at this, for instance, how dreadful is it!
http://www.ehattons.com/52676/Bachmann_Branchline_37_712C_8_Ton_cattle_wagon_in_BR_bauxite_late_weathered/StockDetail.aspx
When was whitewash golden?
In my own mind I have a fairly clear concept of the way forward, but it isn't going to be easy. Then it is my choice. Which brings me back to the title of this piece.
There have been some excellent post recently by Iain Robinson *, Mike Cougill and Geoff Forster that I both agree with 100% whilst also questioning at a fundamental level.
This is still a hobby, rather than a job or something that really really matters on the great scale of things. Most people in our hobby have a hundred and one other distractions in their lives. How do we evaluate what is good for the hobby at a global level? Look back at railway modelling articles from ten, twenty or thirty years ago and there is no doubt that what is accepted as "average" has improved out of all recognition. Perhaps the best modelling from any of those periods still holds its own - Heckmondwicke still grabs me in a very basic way as a model that just worked, for instance - but look at the mainstream model railway press and if nothing else you'll struggle to spot the use of lichen, and that wasn't always the case. The downside is that perhaps we have a lot of people trying to emulate a certain "look" by following articles that give step by step instructions but is that such a bad thing if it gives people the confidence to go ahead and explore their own boundaries?
In some ways the hobby has never been healthier. Personally, for example, I love the fact that I can order specialist components on line and not have to endure fighting my way past people with a challenging view of what constitutes personal hygiene.
One argument is that in the days when kits and RTR locos were basic people were forced to develop the skills to enhance the models available, but a glance through the model press of the time suggests this just meant the starting position was set a lot lower than it is today. The builder of the typical K's kit didn't build their own chassis and fit finescale wheels. Today, faced with a basically adequate RTR loco I find it quite appealing to guild the lily a little by modifying the few things that aren't quite right.
Are there still model layouts out there that are derivative of other models and based on RTR components ? Yes, clearly there are, biut equally there are a lot of models that encapsulate a very individual vision based on both an accurate representation of the prototype and an aesthetic understanding of what makes an attractive and successful layout.
*Since Iain has now discovered this blog I'm going to have to come back to this subject in more depth to explain what I think a modeller like him brings to the table that the rest of us can only try to emulate.
Moving from an OO gauge micro-layout to an EM gauge compromise, via a rather major diversion into both 7 1/4" gauge and minimal space OO9
Labels
Layout Design
Blodwell
Buildings
The Art of Compromise
Photography
Llanrhaiadr Mochnant
Scenery
Signal Box
Baseboards
Goods Yard
Track
45XX
Apa Box
EM
Lcut Creative
Travel
Backscene
Concepts
Railway Exhibitions
TVR
USA
Upwold
14XX
Anyrail
Bridge
Cuba
Cycling
Fencing
Lorry
Narrow Gauge
Point rodding
Points
Templot
Turnouts
West Maryland
Books
C+L
Fiddleyard
GWR
Hales
OO9
Phil Parker
Rolling Stock
Signals
State of the hobby
Tillig
Warley
Weighbridge
trams
2012
AC Railbus
Albion Yard
Allt-y-Graban Rd
Apa Valley
Balloch Pier
Bas
Bath Green Park
Brickwork
Bridgnorth
Bryn-y-Felin
CSX
Charmouth
Clarendon
Class 25
Cliff Railway
Coldrennick Road
Corris
Crich
DCC
Disused Railways
Dukedog
EMGS
Edwin Smith
Electrics
Emett
France
Gloucestershire & Warwickshire
HO
Hobbies
Hope under Dinmore
Hospital Gates
Iain Rice
Iliffe Stokes
Inspiration
Ireland
Kings Lynn
La Baraque
Lasercut
Leamington & Warwick
Locos
MSTS
Mainly Trains
Military Modeling
Mishaps
N guage
NEC
OOn3
Percy
Pier Railway
Porth y Waen
Preserved Railways
RTR
SMP
Seend
Sentinel
Sketchup
St Minions
Stockholm
TGV
TRAX
Tansey Bank
Techniques
Technology
Tim Horn
Trade
Trees
Ultrascale
Veldhoveh 1935
Watertank
Williamsport
diorama
manning wardle
painting
procrastination
pug
ships
simulators
Thursday 3 October 2013
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Firstly, thank you for your very flattering comments. I am honoured to be mentioned alongside Geoff Forster and Mike Cougill. I had to grin when I saw that!
ReplyDeleteI agree with you when you say that the best modelling from every period stands out. Heckmondwyke is a classic, one that still amazes me. Off at a tangent, I would be proud to have built something like George Iliffe Stokes made at any time. Marthwaite, too, from an earlier period. I could go on...:-) Nowadays, I see models that are so good that I am slightly disappointed when I see something on them that isn't absolutely perfect. At which point I have to administer a rap across my own knuckles, because that person is, as you say, doing it for fun, and in competition with work, family and other interests. It is supposed to be fun, not a chore,and my own work falls far from perfect.
I'd hate for the hobby to become like my oil-related work, where a team of people scrutinise every aspect of my model, picking out bits that aren't correct and giving me grief.
I also agree with you about the current ready-to-run. The potential for satisfaction is that there is always something that can be improved, weathered, made finer...however far you want to go. And at the end of the day, that's what it boils down to. How far you are prepared to go, to satisfy yourself. Your journey to that goal is also a very interesting one...
I've put your excellent blog on my blogroll, by the way!
cheers, Iain
My parents knew George and Doris through my father's model shop, but I never met them. Wandering around the Great Electric Train Show this weekend it certainly struck me that there are a lot of avoidable mistakes that constantly get repeated, but also much that was exceedingly good and inspiring.
Delete